| Sheffield Wednesday 1909-1910 |
| Total | 60 |
|---|---|
| Andrew Wilson | 12 |
| Frank Rollinson | 10 |
| Sam Kirkman | 7 |
| Tom Brittleton | 6 |
| Harry Chapman | 6 |
| Frank Foxall | 5 |
| Frank Bradshaw | 3 |
| George Robertson | 3 |
| Andrew Hunter | 2 |
| James Murray | 2 |
| Frank Stringfellow | 2 |
| Billy Lloyd | 1 |
| Oliver Tummon | 1 |