| Sheffield Wednesday 1895-1896 |
| Total | 44 |
|---|---|
| Fred Spiksley | 10 |
| Harry Davis | 8 |
| Lawrence Bell | 7 |
| Alec Brady | 4 |
| Archie Brash | 3 |
| Tommy Crawshaw | 3 |
| Harry Brandon | 2 |
| Jack Earp | 1 |
| Bob Ferrier | 1 |
| Bill Gooing | 1 |
| Jimmy Jamieson | 1 |
| Ambrose Langley | 1 |
| Bob Petrie | 1 |
| Arthur Richards | 1 |