| Sheffield United 1895-1896 |
| Total | 40 |
|---|---|
| Harry Hammond | 9 |
| William Egan | 4 |
| James Draper | 3 |
| Harry Howard | 3 |
| Nudger Needham | 3 |
| William Ross | 3 |
| Arthur Watson | 3 |
| Jimmy Yates | 3 |
| Bob Cain | 1 |
| John Docherty | 1 |
| Joseph Frew | 1 |
| Robert Hill | 1 |
| Jack Jones | 1 |
| Hugh Morris | 1 |
| J Richardson | 1 |
| George Waller | 1 |
| Untraced | 1 |